| 
DL-H v Devon Partnership NHS Trust and Secretary of State for Justice | 
|   | 
  | 
| Issue:  | 
Whether arguments can be raised on an appeal to the Upper Tribunal beyond those raised when permission to appeal was granted; the approach of the Upper Tribunal to a judgment of the First-tier Tribunal; whether it was necessary to consider “proportionality” as well as the statutory test for release in ss72/73 Mental Health Act 1983; whether the Tribunal was bound to discharge on the facts; whether the reasons given were adequate; the approach as to the discretion as to disposal in the Upper Tribunal. | 
|   | 
  | 
| Court:  | 
Upper Tribunal (AAC) | 
|   | 
  | 
| Reference:    | 
M/1653/2009 | 
|   | 
  | 
| Neutral Citation:    | 
[2010] UKUT 102 (AAC) | 
|   | 
  | 
| Judge(s):  | 
UTJ Jacobs | 
|   | 
  | 
| Date:  | 
12 April 2010 |